Permacomputing is a practice of prefigurative politics: means and ends politically align.

It matters what kinds of methods are used to develop a project that wants to support and work towards social and environmental justice. If means and ends are not in alignment, you are not moving towards your goal but moving away from it, ending up in an unintended final destination and often reproducing harm.

Anarchist feminist activist Clara Wichmann argued for the significance of the unity of means and ends:

"Time and again, this has been the tragedy: that people were led astray from their noble goal precisely when—in an effort to reach it all the sooner—they took it upon themselves to adopt means that were unworthy of that goal. This is no abstract ethic, but the most demonstrable reality. The end is not independent of the means, nor are the means independent of the end, because every action carries its own consequences."1

Errico Malatesta emphasised the almost inevitable nature of disregarding this principle:

“Every means tends to achieve its natural end, even against the will of those who employ it.”2

Practical Example

If your community wishes to reuse old hardware to reduce their environmental impact, you could use LLMs offered by large multinational corporations to quickly develop some software.

However, this further entrenches your community in a position of dependency, vendor-lockin and promotes the monopolistic power of the corporations providing LLM services.

Additionally, it reproduces the social and environmental harms done by corporations offering LLMs at a larger scale: from PTSD-ed ghost-workers in the Global South to the massive environmental cost of gas turbine powered AI data centres and everything in between.

Instead you could collectively reflect on what the community needs, using or developing a tool set that allows for independent governance and modification to match those local needs, that doesn't harm other humans and non-humans.


  1. Clara Wichmann, 1924, About the significance of the means for the ends, In: Bevrijding, Arnhem: van Loghum Slaterus en Visser (translated from Dutch).↩
  2. Malatesta, 1989, Socialism and Anarchy, In: Anarchists, Socialists, and Communists, São Paulo: Cortez.↩